How gender impacts decision making within an interactive environment and how this can be translated into level design within games.
Brief
Outline of Work
The key concept behind this final project is
to explore the psychology of gaming and how players of differing genders
respond when presented with decisions within an interactive environment. The
aim is to implement the results into designing and creating levels that
influence the player in relation to a projects chosen target audience.
The overall aim is to create a test level
consisting of a series of left and right turns, each of which, presenting the
player with the choice of two varying stimuli. Examples of such stimuli will
include, but aren’t limited to; light vs dark corridor, bright colour vs dark colour
corridor, small vs larger corridor and loud vs quiet corridor. A hypothesis
will then be generated regarding each possible choice based upon psychological
research and reading as described in the bibliography.
The test level will be created using Unreal 4
as the game engine, as it contains features, such as, the BSP brushes and
blueprints to enable quick prototypes to be created. This decision aims to save
time in the development process so more time can, therefore, be designated to
the play testing and evaluation of the results. The level is to be created in
3D and played using a 1st person camera. This decision is due to the
player stereotypically feeling more immersed in the environment, as the
character they are playing represents themselves in the given scenario. This
therefore leads the experience feeling more personal to them.
The test level will be presented to the
subjects through either Windows PC or mobile platform, dependant on
availability and ease of access at the time. The use of two platforms to
collect data allows for a larger sample size to be collected, as it opens up
the experiment to subjects in various locations and situations.
Test subjects will be of varying age, race
and background to allow for a wide number of factors to be considered. This
will, in turn, allow for more accurate and reliable results from the
experiment. It is planned to collect data from a variety of sources, such as,
peers, friends, family, as well as people on the street around campus and
surrounding areas. This is in attempt to collect a diverse range of responses
to the level. Subjects will be prompted by the level to give their gender and
age before starting to play. It is planned to give no prior knowledge, to the
subject, on what the test level is attempting to achieve. This enables subjects
to enter the test unbiased and with no prior concepts on what the goal is and
therefore, what they “should” choose.
Once sufficient data is collected, they will
be put into excel, allowing for graphs and tables to be better created to
represent the findings in a clear and concise manner. This, also, allows for
the use of statistical analyses to better quantify and understand the data
collected, therefore, allowing direct comparisons with the hypothesis. The
results will, then, be written up, in the form of a scientific report style
artefact.
To summarise, the proposed artefact will
consist of a scientific report in relation to the findings of previously
discussed test level and experiment, both of which will be handed in as the
final artefact. The aim of the experiment is to use the results to better
understand what effects decision making in games and, therefore, implement the
findings into designing and creating levels that influence the player in
relation to a projects chosen target audience.
Rationale
for the Project
The reason for planning to present my
artefact in the form of a scientific experiment, based on the psychological
behaviours and decision making of players within video games, is due to my keen
interest in not only psychology itself, but also level design as a future
career pathway. I feel this artefact would enable the development of skills
required in such career.
By using Unreal 4 engine and understanding
player motivations and how they make decisions within games I am at a higher
employability level for the discussed position of level designer. This
conclusion is based on a number of job adverts that I have explored.
One
such advert states, ‘An understanding of learning curves, pacing, and player
motivations’ (Sumo Digital, 2016), as well as,
‘An ability to weave artistic themes together with core mechanics to build
immersive gameplay experiences’ (Sumo Digital, 2016)
are key skills required for the role of level designer within the company. The
overall experience of creating the experiment and analysing the results will
lead to key skills for employability such as I ‘will know how to use telemetry
data and the results of user tests to fine-tune and balance the levels [I]
create’ (Playstation Jobs, 2016).
The decision to use Unreal 4 engine for the
making of the test level directly links to key skills needed within a career in
level design. An example of this is a job advert which requires the ability to,
‘Create level prototypes and final in-game
levels using Unreal Editor and Unreal’s scripting system (Blueprint)’ (Games
Industry, 2016) as well as have, ‘Strong skill
with Unreal 4 or similar engine’ (Games Industry,
2016).
In summary,
I feel the final artefact would be an excellent addition to a portfolio, to
showcase my skills, as well as understanding of player psychology and decision
making. It will also allow the showcasing of my knowledge of Unreal 4 engine
and how the use of prototypes tie these key concepts together to keep target audience
in mind when creating final levels for a game.
Reference
List
Games
Industry. (2016). Level Designer (f/m). [online] Available at:
http://jobs.gamesindustry.biz/yager-development/germany/uk-and-europe/level-designer--f-m--id87661
[Accessed 13 Nov. 2016].
Games
Industry. (2016). Games Jobs - Game Design - Manchester. [online]
Available at:
http://jobs.gamesindustry.biz/aardvark-swift/manchester/north-west/england/uk-and-europe/experienced-level-designer-id83518
[Accessed 13 Nov. 2016].
Playstation
Jobs. (2016). Level/Mission designer. [online] Available at:
https://www.playstationjobs.co.uk/vacancy/1612-Level/Mission-designer/page/4?src=JB-10380
[Accessed 13 Nov. 2016].
Sumo
Digital. (2016). Level Designer - SUMO SHEFFIELD. [online] Available at:
https://careers-sumo-digital.icims.com/jobs/1154/level-designer---sumo-sheffield/job?mobile=false&width=1713&height=500&bga=true&needsRedirect=false&jan1offset=0&jun1offset=60
[Accessed 13 Nov. 2016].
Annotated
Bibliography
(Please arrange bibliographical items in alphabetical order using a Harvard-style form of presentation)
(Please arrange bibliographical items in alphabetical order using a Harvard-style form of presentation)
|
|
Bibliographical
item
|
Summary
|
|
1.
|
Cash, A. (2002). Psychology for Dummies. 2nd
ed. New York: Hungry Minds.
|
Provides
brief and simplistic background on the key principles of psychology
|
|
2.
|
Eyal, N. (2014). Hooked. 1st ed. London:
Penguin Books Ltd.
|
The
book outlines how to build a habit forming product. This is useful in my test
level as it will enable me to learn key ways of making the level fun for the
player
|
|
3.
|
Fox, J. (2014). The Game Changer: : How to Use
the Science of Motivation with the Power of Game Design to Shift Behaviour,
Shape Culture and Make Clever Happen. 1st ed. Milton: John Wiley &
Sons Australia Ltd.
|
Provides
a key link between psychology and game design to help bridge the gap between
the two topics and help show the relationship between the two
|
|
4.
|
Freud, S. (1975). The psychopathology of everyday
life. 1st ed. Harmondsworth, Middlesex, England: Penguin Books.
|
Is
a key individual in the world of psychology and will help to hypothesis the
outcomes of the results of the experiment
|
|
5.
|
Fullerton, T., Swain, C. and Hoffman, S.
(2004). Game design workshop.
1st ed. San Francisco, Calif.: CMP.
|
Outlines
basic principles of game and level design to help better understand how these
findings can be implemented
|
|
6.
|
Helgeson, V. (2002). The psychology of gender. 1st
ed. Upper Saddle River, N.J.: Prentice Hall.
|
Connects
the theories of gender psychology to the experiment to hopefully provide some
reasoning as to why the results turn out how they do
|
|
7.
|
Kinzie, M. and Joseph, D. (2008). Gender
differences in game activity preferences of middle school children:
implications for educational game design. Educational
Technology Research and Development, [online] 56(5-6). Available at:
http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11423-007-9076-z [Accessed 12 Nov.
2016].
|
A
large portion of the subjects I plan to test are going to be school children
age, therefore, this text will allow me to understand the gender differences
within the age group
|
|
8.
|
Levy, J. (2016). Why We Do The Things We Do.
1st ed. London: Michael O'Mara Books Ltd.
|
Will
help to hypothesis the outcomes of the results of the experiment
|
|
9.
|
Powell, M. and Ansic, D. (1997). Gender
differences in risk behaviour in financial decision-making: An experimental
analysis. Journal of
Economic Psychology, [online] 18(6). Available at:
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0167487097000263 [Accessed
13 Nov. 2016].
|
Will
help with hypothesising and planning the different choices to hopefully
encourage certain preferences and risk behaviour within genders
|
|
10.
|
Schell, J. (2008). The
Art of Game Design.
1st ed. Amsterdam: Taylor & Francis Group, LLC.
|
General
text for game design that the base of my knowledge stems from
|
|
11.
|
Stephen, A.
(2016). Why We Think The
Things We Think. 1st ed. London: Michael O'Mara Books Ltd.
|
Will
help to hypothesis the outcomes of the results of the experiment
|
|
Project Milestones
|
||
|
2016 -- 17
|
Week #
|
Milestone
Deliverables and Tasks
|
|
26 – 30 Sept
|
Week 1
|
|
|
3 – 7 Oct
|
Week 2
|
|
|
10 – 14 Oct
|
Week 3
|
|
|
17 – 21 Oct
|
Week 4
|
|
|
24 – 28 Oct
|
Week 5
|
|
|
31 Oct – 4 Nov
|
Week 6
|
|
|
7 – 11 Nov
|
Week 7
|
|
|
14 – 18 Nov
|
Week 8
|
Submission
of Final Project Proposal: by noon, Friday 18 Nov 2016
|
|
21 – 25 Nov
|
Week 9
|
Beginning
prototype for the test level
|
|
28 Nov – 3 Dec
|
Week 10
|
Have working
prototype for the test level
|
|
5 – 9 Dec
|
Week 11
|
Finalised
test level ready for play testing
|
|
12 – 16 Dec
|
Week 12
|
Begin play
testing over christmas
|
|
19 – 23 Dec
|
|
|
|
26 – 30 Dec
|
Winterval
|
|
|
2 – 6 Jan
|
||
|
9 – 13 Jan
|
|
|
|
16 – 20 Jan
|
|
|
|
23 – 27 Jan
|
Week 13
|
Begin
compiling results into excel
|
|
30 Jan – 4 Feb
|
Week 14
|
Create
presentation
|
|
6 – 10 Feb
|
Week 15
|
Seminar Presentations
|
|
13 – 17 Feb
|
Week 16
|
Seminar Presentations
|
|
20 – 24 Feb
|
Week 17
|
Conduct more
play testing
|
|
27 Feb – 3 Mar
|
Week 18
|
Conduct more
play testing
|
|
6 – 10 Mar
|
Week 19
|
Compile all
results into excel
|
|
13 – 17 Mar
|
Week 20
|
Analysis and
stats of results
|
|
20 – 24 Mar
|
Week 21
|
Finalise
write up
|
|
27 – 31 Mar
|
Week 22
|
Finalise
write up
|
|
3 – 7 Apr
|
Week 23
|
Finalise
write up
|
|
10 – 14 Apr
|
Spring Fertility Festival
|
|
|
17 – 21 Apr
|
||
|
24 – 28 Apr
|
Week 24
|
Submission of Final Product and Blog: by noon, Fri
28 Apr 2017
|